The Netflix case: Cannibalise your products before the Market Does

GM CB _Micheal Jjingo

By Michael Jjingo, General Manager, Commercial Banking at Centenary Bank

By Michael Jjingo

Cannibalism? Aaah, this is a dangerous word in corporate strategy.  It appears in board papers, risk registers and investment committees with a sure red flag. A new product may take customers from an existing product. Revenues may migrate. Margins may fall. The risk team sees danger. But sometimes, what looks like cannibalisation is actually insurance against extinction. The more important question is not, “Will this new product cannibalise our existing product?” It is: “If we do not cannibalise ourselves, who will?”

Netflix offers one of the most powerful examples. It built a successful DVD-by-mail business. Customers ordered films online and received physical DVDs through the post. Then came streaming. Streaming threatened the economics of the business Netflix had already built because every customer who streamed could potentially watch fewer DVDs. A conventional risk committee could easily have called this product cannibalisation. Netflix chose a different interpretation. It understood that the real competitor was not streaming against DVDs. The real competitor was Netflix against the future.

Netflix deliberately moved customers from the business that had made it successful toward the business that could keep it relevant. Eventually, the DVD business disappeared. The extraordinary lesson is that Netflix did not protect its successful product from cannibalisation. It used its successful product to finance its replacement.

This is the uncomfortable truth about corporate longevity: sometimes the greatest threat to a successful business is the success of the business itself. Clayton Christensen captured this in The Innovator’s Dilemma. Established companies are often not destroyed because they are badly managed; they are destroyed because they are managed rationally around the economics of yesterday. The better the existing product performs, the stronger the argument becomes for protecting it. And that is precisely the trap.

Peter Drucker warned against “yesterday’s logic.” Yesterday’s logic says: protect existing revenue. Tomorrow’s logic asks: protect the institution. That distinction applies to almost every industry.

This is where risk management needs to evolve. It should not only ask whether a new product creates risk for an existing product. It should also ask whether refusing to launch the new product creates a greater existential risk. There is a difference between cannibalisation risk and obsolescence risk. Cannibalisation says: our new product may take some business from our old product. Obsolescence says: if we do nothing, somebody else may take the entire market. The first is measurable. The second can be catastrophic.

Not every loss of existing revenue is therefore a bad outcome. Sometimes revenue must migrate before the customer migrates. Sometimes an organisation must deliberately make yesterday’s product less important so tomorrow’s product can become more important.

A company may hesitate to launch a cheaper digital service because it could reduce traditional sales. A retailer may fear e-commerce because customers could buy online rather than in stores. A publisher may resist digital content because it could reduce printed editions. A manufacturer may hesitate to automate because automation could make existing production methods redundant. Every decision can be defended. That is precisely the danger.

An organisation can become so good at protecting existing revenue that it becomes extraordinarily efficient at protecting itself from the future. Jeff Bezos built Amazon around a different philosophy: obsess over the customer rather than the existing business model. Customers do not owe companies loyalty to particular products, channels or technologies. If a better solution appears, they will move. The organisation must therefore be prepared to move first.

This does not mean recklessly destroying profitable products. It means distinguishing healthy cannibalisation from destructive cannibalisation. Healthy cannibalisation moves customers from an ageing economic model into a stronger future model. Destructive cannibalisation merely transfers revenue without creating strategic advantage.

Leadership should ask: Does the new product increase customer lifetime value? Does it deepen the relationship? Does it create new markets? Does it lower costs? Does it create capabilities competitors will struggle to replicate? Does it protect the company against emerging disruption? If yes, cannibalisation may not be a risk. It may be the strategy.

The most dangerous question in strategy is: “How do we protect our most successful product?” A better question is: “If we were our most dangerous competitor, how would we make this product obsolete?” Then build that solution ourselves.

In conclusion, the strongest organisations become both incumbent and challenger. They do not wait for disruption. They invite it into the boardroom, study it, fund it and, when necessary, allow it to compete against their own legacy businesses. Markets rarely disappear overnight. They migrate quietly. Customers begin using something different. Competitors learn faster. Talent follows opportunity. The old model still looks profitable, until suddenly it does not.

The writer is the General Manager Commercial Banking at Centenary Bank.


GOT A HOT STORY? BLOW THE WHISTLE!

Have breaking news, explosive revelations, juicy leads or evidence of wrongdoing?

WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU!

Send your tips, documents, videos, photos and audio recordings to:

redpeppertips@gmail.com

Whether it’s corruption, scandals, abuse of office, injustice or stories others are afraid to tell, help us bring the truth to light.

SOURCES ARE PROTECTED.

CONFIDENTIALITY IS OUR NO.1 PRIORITY!

About Post Author